
Every heist-movie enthusiast has memorized the diner scene from Heat, but don’t overlook a subsequent line of dialogue from Robert De Niro’s expert thief during a robbery, when he reassures cowering customers that he isn’t plundering their kids’ college fund: “We’re here for the bank’s money, not your money; your money’s insured by the federal government, you’re not gonna lose a dime.” How to Rob a Bank, the glib, obnoxious new thriller from David Leitch, turns that advisory into something of a campaign slogan. Whereas the crew of Michael Mann’s epic prided itself on cloak-and-dagger anonymity, the bandits here are peacocking influencers, boasting about their exploits to a sea of online admirers. During one chase sequence, they commandeer a bystander’s BMW on the freeway, and rather than responding with terror, he reacts like he’s finally meeting his favorite celebrities. “Is this How to Rob a Bank? I love your show!”
Why wouldn’t he? Ryan, the leader of the titular self-help group (they also go by the moniker Who’s Hungry), bears the piercing blue eyes of Nicholas Hoult, though the Briton has traded in his buttoned-down eloquence for bleached-blond hair and a pinched American accent. He runs his team—the other members include the tech guy (Rhenzy Feliz), the muscle (Pete Davidson), and the wheelman (Anna Sawai), though the latter is actually a woman (and Ryan’s fiancée)—with the crisp efficiency of a brand manager who wants to maximize social engagement. Armed with blanks and animal masks, they’re as interested in gaining followers as dollars, promoting their heists with elaborate videos—blizzards of graphics, symbols, and QR codes. They even etch the phrase “like and subscribe” onto their gear, and the results are undeniable; their latest upload garners 900 million views.

This may sound absurd, but the premise of How to Rob a Bank, which was written by Mark Bianculli, is that Who’s Hungry has tapped into a particularly fraught zeitgeist of youthful resentment. Beyond simply serving as criminal tutorials (deposits are fattest on Fridays, throw cops off the scent with a cross-town diversion, etc.), their internet missives decry an array of modern institutional abuses: predatory lending, late-stage capitalism, police brutality. In turn, their robberies aren’t motivated by personal greed but by a loftier form of reprisal—a grass-roots revolution designed to drive a stake into the vampiric heart of society’s inequity.
“They have a whole Robin Hood thing going on, it’s punk,” says Reagan (Zoë Kravitz), a brilliant but disgraced programmer—we first meet her clouded in bong smoke, under house arrest, with a Cheeto nestled in her hair—who’s been recruited by the FBI for her expertise in combinatorics (a real word!) to help locate the elusive outlaws. (Her proprietary software is called FYPOS, an acronym that comprises 40% profanity.) Her assessment dumbfounds her supervisor (John C. Reilly), who reminds her that “they’re committing felonies, they’re terrorizing civilians.” That may seem like a fair counterargument, but this is no dialectical seminar. With its flashy editing and its relentless insouciance, How to Rob a Bank plainly sides with Ryan and his crew, portraying them as noble crusaders practically goaded into a life of crime. To oppose them is to support the man, and to dislike this movie is to signal your shameful complicity in the country’s systemic wrongs.

Yeah, well, lock me up I guess. How to Rob a Bank is too fast-paced to be boring, but it’s coated with an insufferable archness that neuters it of any potential provocation. (For example, whether social media companies face a moral or legal obligation to censor the gang’s videos is an abstractly intriguing question that the script swiftly sidesteps.) Leitch’s style-over-substance method turns his characters into ciphers, which makes Ryan’s grim backstory only ring more false. The movie pretends to rage against income inequality, but its smugness renders it more aligned with the fat-cat bankers it’s demonizing. It’s a cop in robbers’ clothing.
Beyond that, How to Rob a Bank is only fitfully entertaining as a heist picture. Leitch’s prior film was The Fall Guy, a charming ode to cinematic stunt work that leveraged the chemistry between Ryan Gosling and Emily Blunt to overcome a shaky story. He throws in a few passable action sequences here, but he’s too preoccupied with quippy visual flourishes to craft pulse-pounding set pieces. He also exhibits a clumsy command of atmosphere, resulting in scenes that are either irritatingly slick or painfully saccharine.

What’s frustrating is that when How to Rob a Bank manages to calm down, it can be pleasant company. That’s most evident in the rapport between Kravitz and Reilly, who predictably underline their generational disparity (“How did you get your computer on the TV that fast??”) but also develop genuine warmth. Less successful are Hoult and Sawai, two beautiful actors who are hamstrung by a screenplay that refuses to imbue them with any dimensionality.
Ultimately, even How to Rob a Bank’s appealing qualities feel derivative of older, better pictures. “I became an FBI agent because I love the movie Point Break,” Reilly’s fed says. So do I, even if I question how its final image—a dispirited Keanu Reeves chucking his badge into the ocean—might inspire someone to enroll in the police academy. But Leitch’s filmmaking lacks both the verve and the precision of Kathryn Bigelow’s work, while the script’s purported fury over financial malfeasance lacks the milieu-driven texture of Hell or High Water. Even Crime 101, which blatantly ripped off Heat earlier this year, operated with a seriousness of purpose; no doubt Leitch would deride such sincerity as uncool, even as he borrows its plot point about a thief pulling all of his heists along the same stretch of roadway.

Tonally, How to Rob a Bank tries to have it both ways, beginning as a frolicsome caper before transitioning into a gritty, tough-as-nails thriller. There’s valor in that sort of ambition, but the execution here results in a double half-measure—insufficiently charismatic to be crowd-pleasing, not rigorous enough to be hard-hitting. These guys may be good at robbing banks, but the only thing this movie steals is the cost of your ticket.
Grade: C
Jeremy Beck is the editor-in-chief of MovieManifesto. He watches more movies and television than he probably should.